Website focus: Reviews of studies and forensic examinations. The specific objects, questions, materials and form of deliverable are agreed before work begins.
What a review examines
A review considers the quality of an existing report: the sufficiency of source data, description of the objects, methods used, completeness of the examination and logical connection between the results obtained and the findings. It does not replace a substantive examination of the objects themselves.
Main review questions
- Does the examination address the questions posed?
- Are the materials used and limitations described?
- Are the methods and sources explained?
- Do the findings follow from the analysis?
- Are there contradictions, omissions or unsupported statements?
Materials for a review
The complete report with appendices, the appointment document or brief, materials relevant to the examination and specific objections are needed. If only individual pages are provided, only those pages can be assessed, with the limitation expressly stated.
Result
The agreed deliverable sets out the deficiencies identified and their supporting reasoning and, where needed, questions to clarify the examination. Decisions on an additional or repeat examination and the assessment of evidence are made by an authorised person.
Discuss the task through the website form · Terms of service