What needs to be clarified
The review aims to trace the evidence behind the disputed conclusion and determine whether the examined object can be identified unambiguously.
Materials to prepare
- The complete report with all appendices
- The assignment and list of submitted objects
- Information on document versions and corrections
What to compare
- Compare designations in the assignment, description and appendices.
- Check whether renaming or replacement illustrations are explained.
- Distinguish a correctable inaccuracy from a contradiction affecting the reasoning.
Possible outcome of the analysis
The review can describe the discrepancy, identify the relevant pages and propose questions for clarification or further examination.
Limits of the conclusions
A missing appendix cannot be replaced by an assumption; a review does not itself invalidate the report or establish a new examination result.